|
From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3-Muth has taken this old tale and transplanted it from its
traditional European setting to China. The tricksters are no longer
hungry travelers or soldiers but Buddhist monks. Their goal in fooling
the villagers is not to fill their own stomachs but rather to enlighten
them about the happiness that comes from sharing. Muth's characteristic
watercolor illustrations, with their striking use of misty hues
contrasted with bright primaries, are expertly done and convey a
distinct sense of place. In his author's note, the reteller details the
elements of Chinese folklore that he incorporated into the story as well
as the symbols from Eastern culture used in the artwork. However, Muth's
decision to alter the motivation of the tricksters also depresses some
of the humor in the story and gives it a moralistic tone. In addition,
the likelihood that these initially suspicious and reclusive villagers
would become truly happy people as a result of their own gullibility is
slim. This is a beautifully executed book with a flawed story line.
Grace Oliff, Ann Blanche Smith School, Hillsdale, NJ
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc. |
